Milo and Willow_edited.png

If you're in the Freehold area, look no further! We have two cats who are our little babies (Milo and Willow) so when we booked a 2 week trip we were so nervous to leave them but -Milo, Willow and I couldn’t of been happier after finding Carly ! Carly is amazing she took care of them for 12 nights straight and did an amazing job. It’s hard to find someone that can be trusted to come into your home and take care of your babies so we are thrilled! She did a meet and greet first and sent us picture updates every day we were away -also left our house spotless we didn’t have to worry at all! It was such a great feeling. Carly will be my designated cat sitter from now on ?
Nicole Butler (732)-713-7501

Milo and Willow


Carly is a fantastic dog walker ! She is always on time , reliable , stays longer & always communicates with me each visit with my dog . I have a 2yr old chocolate Lab & she is very active & needs a lot of exercise . Carly walks / runs with my dog at least 1 mile a day & then plays with her & gives her much happy attention & tender loving care !! I feel My dog & my house are always safe & in good hands with Carly !!!
Rich Magan (732)-691-7114



Carly is an absolute God send. She’s so sweet and caring with our little Sadie!! She is always communicative and keeps us updated. She’s flexible with our schedule and incredibly reliable. An added bonus are the adorable photos she shares with each visit! I feel so blessed to have found Carly!! Keep up the great work!
Alyson Hudson



Best Paw First is reliable, professional and an absolute needle in a haystack.  My dog bonded with the walker right away and Dash is always SO excited for his walks!  Best Paw First is honest, dependable, friendly and I just can’t be more thrilled it has become an invaluable new addition to my dog’s life 🐶🐾
Genine Barnett (917)- 523-4148


Angel and Roxie_edited.jpg

I cannot say enough great things about Carly. My pups are slow to warm up to new people and they were kissing her almost immediately after meeting Carly for the first time. She's easy to work with, great at communicating, reliable and goes above and beyond to make sure the pups are happy and comfortable.
I will definitely be using her again.
Robin Rosenhaus

Angel and Roxie


Just stayed to write another review, because if you’re like me, you rely heavily on them. I can’t stress enough how happy we are to have Carly working with our fur baby. We love having her, and refuse to use any one else. She is so great with our pup and we know she LOVES Carly right back. We always feel like we’re in good hands and trust Carly wholeheartedly! Don’t hesitate to book with her.
Bowie D


Sadie and Crytal 2.jpg

We were caught in a Catch 22 because we were traveling out of state & couldn’t find last minute boarding. A friend recommended Rover & it was the best decision! Carly was amazing with our Sadie and Crystal & they loved her too. Daily pictures, texts & updates were a treat as last service we used sent NOTHING! She made it easy for us to feel very comfortable leaving part of our family in her care. I will definitely use & recommend this sweetheart of a girl to my friends!
Cathie Guadgno

Sadie and Crystal

Me, Patch, and Cinder_edited.jpg

Finding Carly to walk and take care of our puppies has been a true blessing for my husband and I.  You assume that when you hire a dog walker, they will naturally be attentive in the time allotted with your pet.  What we have discovered with Carly is that she goes above and beyond the typical “walk” every single visit.  Carly ensures that each puppy gets the affection and attention that any puppy/dog craves.  She can individualize them all while playing together in group play which is an excellent bonding exercise.  Carly sends cute and playful pictures each day with a report on how the day went leaving my husband and I feeling reassured while we are unable at work.  She has even gone so far as to clean up after one of our lil pups had an accident to the extent that I had nothing to freshen up when I came home from work.  This example displays above and beyond help that was not contracted…she just did what she thought was right and helpful,… which certainly reflects her compassionate nature .  Carly has several outstanding assets including reliability, respectfulness, responsiveness, passion, and empathy.    Most importantly, Carly is trustworthy.  We, in good consciousness, trust Carly with our home and with our family without any doubt or concern, which alleviates any worry we may have had when leaving our household to a stranger.  That brings me to my last point….Carly has become a friend and an asset in our family that we truly appreciate.  I would like to think that Carly is part of the pack, lol ;)…..and our dogs adore her,… as do we ;)
Cassandra Patuto (201) 926-6460

Patch and Cinder

cleveland official.jpg

Carly has always been fantastic with my dog Cleveland. She is a terrific communicator and always responds very fast. She’s also helped me when I’ve been in a pinch and needed a walker when I’ve had to work longer hours. Carly will always be my go to person for my dog.
Ryan McBrinn +1 (551)-580-9169



Carly is an amazing pet sitter! I am so thankful I found her. I have used her on numerous occasions to do drop-in visits for my animals while I am at work during the day. I am a repeat client and could not imagine hiring anyone else!

Carly is dependable, trustworthy, and an excellent communicator. All-in-all, she is a true professional. I know that I can count on her… and I am v. protective of my fur children!! Upon our first meet and greet, I knew that her positive demeanor and genuine compassion for animals would provide me with the comfort that I need to leave my pets in the care of a sitter.

During the drop-in visit she takes my dog for a walk and spends time w/ my cats. She provides a very detailed description of her visit each day. She will also send photos!

In terms of service, Carly goes way above and beyond anything I would ever expect of a pet sitter. I can unequivocally state that you will not be disappointed in your decision to hire Carly!
I highly recommend her to anyone --- friends, family, and the community!

--- Christina